EXTENDED CUT! First Impressions: Shadows Over Arcadia by Zacheas.

At five years old, Ren Drakemore was contemplating the moral fabric of kingdoms. At five, I was eating glue.

Core Concepts & Initial Impressions:

I remember my earliest youth—five years old—the crunch of an apple dribbling faintly down my chin as I lounged in contemplation of life’s meaning. Ah, those were trying days, wrestling with the great questions of realm-wide wellbeing and the latest innovations in crop rotation.

At four, I’d invented Pythagoras’ theorem; by five, I’d already applied it to architecture and mechanical design. Yet still, a vast melancholy settled upon my soul—so deep as to be subterranean. Life’s cruel cry for meaning met only universal silence.

I’m sure you all remember your own five-year-old existential crises.

You don’t?

How strange.

Still, that level of reflection would make perfect sense if you were Ren Drakemore, the five-year-old prodigy-protagonist of Shadows Over Arcadia—a child so precocious he makes Plato look developmentally challenged.

If you’re looking for my initial impression, this is it: “Gracious me, that’s a sophisticated five-year-old.”

My second thought followed swiftly after: “The story had better have a darn good reason for this.”

I waited for the revelation of reincarnation… It didn’t come. Transmigration? Not that either. Childhood regression with the wisdom of a future self? Nowhere to be seen. This magical high-fantasy adventure seems to play it straight.

No soul-bound UI. No past lives. No modern Earth knowledge ported down into feudal kingdoms. If any of that lurks within, it comes later—well past the twenty-three chapters I read for this review.

And yet, to my pleasant surprise, Ren’s maturity isn’t hand-waved away. Other characters notice it. The story justifies it. Much the same way my fixation on that one trait is justified—because through it, you already know the tone, the genre, and the kind of tale you’re stepping into.

Clever, right?

What? That’s not enough?

Uhnah! Ask anybody, that was more than enough!

Anybody enters the chat:
Not enough, bruh.

I… I meant anybody else.

Anybody else enters the chat:
Sorry, bro. Got to agree with the last guy.

Foisted!

Alright, fine—I’ll give you more.

We follow the journey of Ren Drakemore, second prince of Arcadia. With his first breath, he heralded his mother’s last—her life freely given to secure his own. Driven mad by grief, King Edric Drakemore raised his hand to strike his newborn son dead, only to be stayed by the intervention of an amoral fae.

This fae—an ancient being of wily contracts and unfathomable power—binds herself to Ren’s care for all his days. To that end, she commandeers a tower in the royal estate and devotes herself to his nurturing and education, rearing him for the day he might seize the crown himself. Her reasoning? The kingdom is so fundamentally broken that the only way to ensure Ren’s safety is to place him upon its throne.

Here’s the thing—she’s kinda got a point. Arcadia is broken. Slavery is commonplace, as is poverty among the common yet free. Education and social advancement are reserved for the nobility. And the nobility themselves? You’d be hard-pressed to find a worse hive of scum and villainy in the seediest dive bar on Tatooine.

Shadows Over Arcadia has much of what you’d expect from a high-fantasy romp on the pages of Royal Road: magic, adventure, Adventurers, beastkin, elves, arcane academies—the works. But don’t be lulled into thinking this is your typical power fantasy, shallow as a puddle spilled from your sippy cup.

The author paints a stunning picture with their prose, though it’s brushed in dim, dark hues. The characters feel—they’re left broken and traumatised. Yet they also hope and dream. They fall in love. Rendered in the first-person present tense, you feel the immediacy of it all.

For me, that’s what elevates Shadows Over Arcadia beyond the mere content its premise could have easily birthed. Through its execution—the craft, the story, the emotional anchors—I can honestly say: Shadows Over Arcadia is a standout piece of web fiction. One, no doubt, destined for further refinement and monetised publication as it grows.

So then, let’s start with…

What Works?

Rotational Perspectives:

Ren Drakemore might be the protagonist—the axis around which the story turns—but Shadows Over Arcadia cycles through its cast with deliberate rotation. You glimpse the king’s machinations from within his own mind and, disturbingly, almost understand why he tried to kill his son. You experience the alien, amoral consciousness of Willow, the fae—her thoughts grinding like clockwork until, somehow, the gears soften into something close to affection. You see Maribel’s trauma through her own eyes, watching the fragile yet resolute street rat strain to hold herself together beneath the weight of a damaged childhood.

Because the story is told through multiple first-person lenses, the author wields dramatic irony like a scalpel. It strikes hardest in the quiet moments—a wary flinch from a touch you understand, because you’ve lived in both minds, yet is invisible to the character reaching out. A gentle lie told in kindness, white by common sense, but to someone burned raw by deceit, that same lie glows not white in innocence, but white-hot with the promise of pain.

Each character is meticulously rendered; the author has mastered their voices. As someone scribbling a multi-perspective narrative myself, I can personally attest to the challenge of crafting and maintaining distinct voices across a cast. This author makes it look like child’s play.

And no—not the overly precious Ren Drakemore, “I can make dolls into people,” kind of child’s play.

Professional Prose:

We’ve got another one—another piece of web fiction with nigh-perfect, professional prose. It’s clean. It’s descriptive. It’s evocative. If there were textual foibles, I didn’t see them. I was too busy being dragged through the story—engrossed, mesmerised, consumed.

Which brings me neatly to an open letter to my girlfriend:

No, I wasn’t ignoring you because I’m a “jerk.” Nor because I “never help around the flat.” Nor even because “oh my God, can you just GIVE ME SOME PEACE—”

I love you. I really do. I was simply… immersed—held hostage by prose so dangerously competent it might constitute emotional negligence.

So if you’re going to blame anyone, blame the author. They’ll be footing the bill for couples counselling. And maybe the takeaway—depending on what my lawyer can negotiate. I’m thinking Popeyes.

(Still angling for that sponsorship.)

Jokes aside, the writing is effective. It has voice and rhythm—long, introspective sentences snapping short for effect. It engages the senses; each scene is vividly rendered. And yet it remains clear, accessible, and easy to digest. Somehow, this author’s done it—offering the technical precision prized by those who cling to craft, while keeping the clarity and lack of pretence cherished by casual readers.

It works. It really does. Both for online publication and for traditional print. All appetites are catered for—and that’s no easy feat.

If I were to offer one minor criticism, it’s that I don’t feel the author takes full advantage of the first-person present perspective they’ve chosen. The form could invite bolder, more experimental streams of consciousness. But like I said, that’s minor—stylistic potential, not a shortcoming. And pushing too far might jeopardise clarity, and then I’d be criticising that instead.

The Story & World:

The story’s deceptively simple—it’s about a boy who wants to be king. The setting feels deeply familiar to anyone versed in fantasy. Yet simplicity and familiarity don’t preclude it from being both engaging and magical. In fact, by lowering the barrier to entry through well-worn tropes, the author makes the world more accessible. But like Hotel California, organised crime, or the secret basement I’m not going to tell you about—once you’re in, you’re in for good.

I mentioned it in my opener, so I won’t rehash the particulars of the story or its world, but I can say this: they’re engaging. The characters and voice might sell the work to me, but the backdrop is no less stunning. For the casuals, it has everything you’d expect from a fantasy on Royal Road. For the obsessives, it grounds you in familiarity while giving the narrative both drive and direction—freeing your mind to explore the deeper layers of the tale being told. You won’t get lost as you dive those depths.

And those depths run dark. They lie in the story’s exploration of systemic rot—nepotism, institutional paranoia, and the irrationality of a kingdom crushing the very people who might have become its bastions, if only they’d been allowed to rise through their own unimpeded effort. The depth is in the questions it raises: the almost game-theory logic of extracting from a people the little they have, instead of reaping a greater harvest through shared flourishing. It begs the question of where that will lead—whether Ren can recognise the sickness in full, and steer Arcadia in a different direction.

Is it groundbreaking in form? No. But it’s solid underfoot—and its execution is what breaks new ground. It works. For me, it absolutely works.

What Might Hold It Back?

The Scene:

Somewhere in this story is a chapter, and in that chapter—a scene. And in that scene lives trauma so heavy it has its own gravitational pull. It adds grit and realism, but for some readers it’ll be a lot to stomach.

The author knows exactly which bit I mean. It isn’t a flaw, but it is a warning label. Even by my warped standards, this thing is dark.

So dark it keeps a torch on its nightstand for moral support.

So dark Batman called to ask for pointers.

So dark it absorbed my screen’s brightness slider and started charging rent.

Ahem… right. Where was I?

IT’S SOOOOO DARK THAT… the NHS now recommends vitamin D supplements after reading it.

Honestly, the scene might even be a touch gratuitous. The implication and insinuation from the prior chapter already carried the same weight without showing the details outright. Was something gained by keeping it? Maybe—but at the cost of pacing, and at the risk of alienating some readers, I don’t think it was worth it.

Closing:

By now, you know what I think of Shadows Over Arcadia. It’s clever, it’s dark, it’s gorgeously written—and I suspect it’s secretly judging me for how long I’ve taken to finish this review.

Zacheas has done what most web authors dream of but few pull off: taken the well-worn trappings of fantasy and made them feel personal again. There’s no reincarnated software engineer saving the kingdom through modern plumbing. No protagonist who levels up by breathing aggressively at rocks. Just pain, purpose, and prose so smooth it could get a date on charm alone.

Is it flawless? No. Nothing with this much heart ever is. But that’s part of the appeal. Like an antique sword—slightly nicked, still lethal—it’s the imperfection that gives it character.

So yes—read it. Read it because it reminds you what web fiction can be when someone actually cares. Read it because you want to feel something sharp and human. Read it because you, too, once thought deeply about crop rotation at the age of five.

I’ll be over here, pretending I’m not emotionally compromised by a story about a traumatised royal child and his morally flexible fairy god-tormentor.

• X
• Facebook
• Reddit
• Tumblr

If you enjoyed this and want to help keep Bardic Planet running, you can fuel the Bard’s Death-Ray here.