EXTENDED CUT! First Impressions: Born Under A Black Sun. By Paul Grady.

“This is not a fantasy built to be consumed quickly, but one meant to be lived in.”

Core Premise & Initial Impressions:

Everyone has their issues. Some of us drink too much; for others, it’s food. Maybe your parents pushed you too hard. Maybe they didn’t push you hard enough.

Someone reading this right now is haunted—perhaps by something they’ve done. They might be haunted by something they didn’t do.

Or maybe, just maybe, you ran into a grouchy Gravecaller who went and summoned the spirit of your emasculating tabby cat from beyond her watery grave, and set her on you like a bride on a bride’s maid who went to the wedding wearing a white dress.

That specific example wasn’t found in Born Under A Black Sun, but Teren—the protagonist—does something close. And from that one decision, a world of troubles follow.

Let’s start with the premise.

Born Under A Black Sun is a high-fantasy adventure set across the world of Kirith—interconnected realms with distinct cultures and sharply divided attitudes toward magic. Teren hails from the Sainted Lands, nations named after the eight saints who overthrew their oppressive rulers, the Half-World Nobles.

He’s a Gravecaller—the very kind who might set Princess Cornilia, Fussyboots VII, on you as a permanent reminder that no, it shouldn’t point that way. Yes, she thinks it’s weird. And if you can’t even afford the cuts of tuna she likes, how will you afford to get it fixed?

More specifically, he can talk to ghosts. He can raise the evil-dead and empower spirits to do his will. He can also make people deeply uncomfortable by laughing like a loon, seemingly alone, in the local saloon.

He’s an apprentice, well on the way to being granted a title and official standing within the Gravecaller guild—the Order of Remains.

Together with his master, Rotwood; his Lifeguider friend, Ronic; Ronic’s master, Faststride; and her second apprentice, Baltry, they are set to journey from the Sainted Lands. The destination? The volcanic city of Merdz. The mission? To carry out the whims of a scheming prince.

Mission accepted.

Mission completed.

Mission gone catastrophically awry.

With minimal spoilers, I can say this: Teren creates a city of the dead. For most novels, that would be the conclusion. For Born Under A Black Sun, it is only the beginning.

From there, the journey widens—across foreign lands, in pursuit of a ghost dead set on becoming a god.

When reading a novel, there is a feeling I look for. I used to consider it ineffable—intangible. Whatever it is, it sparks excitement, an urge to get lost in the story’s world. Born Under A Black Sun has that quality—it has it in spades. And as it turns out, the ineffable can be nailed down. As Bard-in-Chief, I take it upon myself to do exactly that. Not unlike a particularly despotic cat.

It comes from the characters and their interactions. From the voice—the wit, the snark, the self-justifications. From an author who trusts the reader to notice throwaway details, so when those details boomerang back, they return with satisfying momentum. And then there is the world itself: detailed enough to be captivating, mysterious enough to be enchanting.

Born Under A Black Sun is terribly good. It captures some of the strongest elements often found in LitRPGs—class-based magic and the inventive ways those constraints are exploited—but it is not a LitRPG. There is no soul-bound UI. No scrolling spell lists. The story plays fantasy straight. Magic is magical, not mechanical. Monsters are man-made, and the only experience gained from killing them is the experience of surviving.

The novel is mature—so is the pacing. It hooks early, develops, escalates, then slows or accelerates according to the story’s needs. If you are looking for endless dopamine loops—level-ups, new skills, new swag—you will not find them here. What you will find instead is something closer to traditional publication. The difference, of course, is that publishing a novel is a team sport. This one was written and edited by a single author.

The prose is good, but not flawless. It lacks the sense that every word fought for its place on the page. That said, this is a high-level problem—the kind you only notice when an author is doing almost everything else right.

So, staying on the theme of what the author does well, let’s take a closer look at…

What Works?

Integrated Exposition:

The exposition is handled extremely well—perfectly integrated through dialogue and context. Kirith is a vast world inhabited by different peoples, cultures, languages, and traditions. There is a great deal to digest. Delivered all at once, it would induce narrative indigestion—the kind that splashes your pipes after a course of fiendish feline chased down with bread and red wine.

And yet the cat still remains…

Ahem.

What I am saying is that Born Under A Black Sun does not overwhelm the reader with everything at once. Instead, it sprinkles information in only when it becomes necessary.

Exposition delivered through dialogue can be a trap; I have read more than a few novels where characters exist solely as walking, talking tutorial prompts. This author is more experienced than that. Expositionary dialogue never feels forced. It arrives in context and, crucially, maintains character voice.

The novel does throw a fair number of unfamiliar terms at you. I raised a brow once or twice at their casual introduction. But I trusted the author, and that trust paid off. You may well need a glossary to keep track of every city, culture, people, and unfamiliar practice the story drops in your lap—like a baleful feline clawing its way back from hell just to bite you—but you do keep pace. The narrative reinforces what matters, grounding you in the essentials and looping back to anything important you might have missed when it truly counts.

Excellent Use of Magic:

As I sit upon my bardic stool and write this review, I am reticent to praise the very same magic that once left me cowering in the corner, hands clamped to my ears, humming to drown out the phantom chiding of my tabby cat.

I know I am not man enough to keep Cornish Rex. I do not need to be reminded.

Ahem.

Jokes aside, the magic suits the story extremely well. Broadly, it is divided into two categories. The first is the Beastly Arts, which encompass animalistic shapeshifting, taming, and the mixing of creatures to create hybrid forms. The second is the Twelve Paths, each granting its wielder control over a specific domain—whether that means whispering wood into new shapes, turning the tides to one’s will, breathing life into wounded flesh, or wielding power over death itself.

The magic doesn’t feel tacked on. The world is shaped by it. In a way, it almost feels mundane—as though navigating a cursed city were a mere inconvenience rather than a paradigm-shifting, existential revelation. Strange things happen. Sometimes the dead walk the streets. But that doesn’t change the price of bread, and people still have their lives to lead.

It feels like mythic times made real—as if the superstitions of the ancient world were true, universally understood, and navigated accordingly. To us, it’s incredible. To them, it’s Tuesday. And nothing’s more mundane than a Tuesday.

The key to good writing lies in constraint. By its very nature, language is constrained. For an utterance to carry one meaning, it must be prevented from bearing others—at least in the same way, at the same time. Mastery comes from working within those limits to produce something that still feels alive.

The author applies that same discipline to the magic system, showcasing inventive ways of working within established boundaries without breaking the world’s internal logic. A Lifebreather might make themselves unnoticed by dimming their connection to the surrounding life. A Gravecaller might erase pain by dulling their nerves. The point is this: in Born Under A Black Sun, the rules are known. The rules are followed. And yet the application can still astound.

Detailed Worldbuilding:

The world of Kirith is both vast and well constructed. At the risk of repeating myself, it feels simultaneously mythical and tactile. And it works.

The effort the author puts into making each culture feel distinct and alive is masterful. You are not told that certain attitudes or practices are alien to the protagonist—you feel it. Likewise, the author does not list cultures and their attributes; you experience them organically as the story moves forward. It is like walking the streets of a foreign city—immersed in customs and norms without ever needing a guidebook.

You can feel the weight of history on the world, and the prejudices that history has left behind. Societies have splintered in different directions, shaped by landscape and magic alike. The result is a setting where culture feels like consequence rather than decoration.

The world is so well constructed it might take a political science master’s degree to fully grasp it—but that is precisely the point. It feels thought-through at every level. I have the distinct sense that I could sit the author down for a Q&A and he would have answers ready. He might need to reference a binder or two, but I have little doubt the details are there.

In fact, if Paul Grady is reading this right now, shoot me a message explaining the primary cultural export of Papanuy.

Characters:

Teren’s a little sociopathic—but he isn’t unlikeable. Quite the opposite. He comes across as extremely affable, right up until you pi$s him off. He’s damaged by his upbringing in ways others can see but he cannot. His rationales are logical, yet twisted. He could very easily be a villain were it not for the genuine warmth he receives from his fellow travellers—and the fact that they keep him pointed roughly away from the worst possible decisions.

Those fellow travellers feel no less human than Teren himself. They have their own quirks and personalities, their own rationales and motivations. The story may centre on Teren, but it does not revolve around him. This is not a world where everyone politely waits their turn to be impressed by the protagonist. Every member of the cast has a role, and they play it damn well.

The result is banter that is genuinely delightful. Other characters’ insights matter. Their reactions feel earned. Conversations do not exist solely to flatter Teren or funnel him toward greatness—they exist because these people would still be talking, arguing, and occasionally exasperating one another even if he were not in the room. Every character earns their place on the page.

What Might Hold It Back?

Typographic Errors & Some Clunky Phrasing:

I cannot stress how minor this is. The writing is effective. It is evocative. Scenes are constructed with the right level of description and a clarity that rarely falters, held back only by a light scattering of typographical errors—the literary equivalent of finding a loose thread on an otherwise excellent tabby cat coat.

I noticed a missing word here and there. A bit of comma-splicing, perhaps. The book would benefit from an editing pass, but the errors are few, and they are superficial rather than structural. Even traditionally published novels—armed with editors, proofreaders, and what I assume is at least one exhausted intern—don’t catch every mistake. I mention it to be honest, not alarmist. It doesn’t harm immersion in any meaningful way.

The same applies to some phrasing I personally found clunky. Every so often, I caught myself thinking, there’s a cleaner way of putting that, or this could sing a little more. But again, this is minor. The prose is already professionally good. To take it to the next level—the level of traditionally published work where every word feels not chosen but inevitable—some of those clunks would need to be smoothed out. But this would be polish, not repair.

Demands Attention:

If you’ve gotten this far in the review, you already know what to expect from this novel. For some of you, what you expect is not what you want—and that’s fine.

You might be looking for something crunchy-addictive, heavy on stat screens and face-slapping. Something easy to digest. Something you can read with your brain switched firmly to standby without missing a beat.

You will not find that here. Born Under A Black Sun demands patience before it pays off, and more attention to its deep, vivid world than you may be willing—or able—to give while half-watching YouTube in the background.

That is not a flaw in the story, and it is not a flaw in that kind of reader. It is simply this: nothing works for everyone. Fortunately, you are well-equipped to know whether this will work for you.

Closing:

Born Under A Black Sun is the kind of novel that reminds you why fantasy works in the first place. Not because it is loud, or fast, or endlessly self-rewarding—but because it is considered. It trusts its world. It trusts its characters. Most importantly, it trusts you.

This is a story built on voice, consequence, and restraint. Its magic feels ancient rather than engineered. Its cultures feel lived-in rather than sketched. Its characters are allowed to be damaged, contradictory, and occasionally alarming without being reduced to archetypes or excuses. The result is a narrative that feels less like content and more like a place you have stepped into—one where the dead might walk, princes scheme, and tomorrow’s catastrophe is already sharpening its teeth.

Is it perfect? No. A tighter editing pass would sand down the occasional rough edge. A line here or there could sing instead of merely speaking. But those are the kinds of flaws you find when you are already enjoying yourself—when you are looking closely because the story has earned your attention.

If you want frictionless escapism, there are other doors you should open. If you want a fantasy that rewards patience, curiosity, and the willingness to meet it halfway, Born Under A Black Sun is well worth your time.

Just… maybe don’t annoy the Gravecaller. Or the cat.

Especially the cat.

• X
• Facebook
• Reddit
• Tumblr

If you enjoyed this and want to help keep Bardic Planet running, you can fuel the Bard’s Death-Ray here.